- Jesus Christ Esack Grueskin
- Judas Iscariot Rob Merritt
- Mary Magdalene Hannah Loeb
- Pontius Pilate Nick Oswald
- Claudia Procula Jessica Wittman
- Caiaphas Dustin Davis
- Annas Ben LaFayette
- High Priests Gary Benser & Rebecca Ogilvie
- Peter Ben Nelson
- Simon Zealotes Skyler Mathias
- King Herod Larry Newman
- Apostles
Rob Beland, John Paul Horn, Jake Kenyon, Jordan LaFauce Ruben Lebron, Marisah Richards, Elizabeth Stam, Renee Zukin - Pilate’s son Andy Stewart
- Homeless woman (Peter’s Denial) Jean Grewe
- Bum (Peter’s Denial) Jeff Koepp
- Drug Dealer (Peter’s Denial) Wesley Tener
- Swing and Principal Understudy Patrick DuLaney
- Ensemble (*featured dancer)
Emma Bluder
Lizzie Carrell
Gabby Finlayson
Taylor Gillhouse*
Claire Green
Paige Harken
Emily Hill
Megan Hill
Alicia Hoecherl
Grace Huber*
Chad Keitel
Jean Knepper
Maxine Koepp
Nicholas LaFayette
Jacques Motyko
Mady Nachtman
Frederic Ogilvie
Ariane Parkes Perret
Makayla Phillips
Kendalyn Pierson
Mary Rethwisch*
Tom Rose
Kristina Rutkowski
Eliza Sanders*
Jesse Schuerer
Robert Steger
Avery Streeby
Miriam Thoe
Tempest Wisdom
Meliza Wise